Home  |  What's New  |  Features  |  Gallery  |  Reviews  |  Reference  |  Forum  |

Arab MiGs Volume 5
October 1973 War: Part 1

by Tom Cooper and David Nicolle
with Lon Nordeen and Martin Smisek

Harpia Publishing LLC

S u m m a r y

Title and Author Arab MiGs (Volume 3) - The 1967 War
by Tom Cooper and David Nicolle, with Lon Nordeen and Patricia Salti.
Illustrator Tom Cooper (profiles)
Publisher: Harpia Publishing, LLC
ISBN: 978-0-9854554-4-6
Media: Softcover, 256 pages, 28 x 21 cm
Price: MSRP (Euro) 35.95 Euro plus p&p from HARPIA
MSRP (USD) $69.95 from CASEMATE (www.casematepublishing.com)
Review Type: First Read
Advantages: Execllent black and white and full colour photos; dozens of inspiring profiles; high quality text.
Disadvantages:  
Recommendation: Highly Recommended

 

Reviewed by David L. Veres


HyperScale is proudly supported by Squadron.com

 

FirstRead

 

Harpia Publishing’s brilliant Arab MiGs series remains among aviation history’s most vital – and vibrant – research quests.  And newly released Volume 5 categorically confirms that.

But whereas previous parts spanned years, this one essentially details days: “Part 1” of the October 1973 War.

As before, “Addenda/Errata” initially adjust, amend, explain and expand the first four volumes.  Contents then segue to illuminating notes on ongoing replenishment efforts, final “War of Attrition” actions, Soviet involvement and combat, and Egypt’s massive anti-aircraft umbrella to shield attacking forces from Israeli air superiority.

Wartime accounts of the Egyptian and Syrian fronts begin the afternoon of 6 Oct 1973.  And once combat coverage commences, the authors competently course through the conflict’s first 48 hours – including commando operations and Iraqi participation.

As before, Harpia’s dramatis personae include more than “MiGs”.  Sukkhois, Skyhawks, Hips and Phantoms – among others – take bows.  And Iraqi Hunters play parts.   But MiG-17s and MiG-21s clearly seize center stage.

Some nitpicks intrude.  My rusty Arabic aside, I’d transliterate Operation Badhr as “Badr”.  What exactly is an “old baby” on page 144?  The unit key is incorrect for the map on page 170.  The acronym “HAS” might baffle novitiates.  And defining “Fall of the Third Commonwealth” and the “Day of Judgment” might better illumine Israel’s visceral panic.

But Harpia’s reliance on eyewitness testimony remains my core concern.  With no official Arab records available, however, the authors frankly admit the risks of calibrating Arab anecdotes against Israeli and other sources.  And they openly “welcome additional information”.

Air orders of battle, tables, sidebars, abbreviations, annotations, selected bibliography, index and five appendices ably augment the account.  Color and B&W photos, diagrams, and maps further support Harpia’s study.

Over 50 of co-author Cooper’s unfailingly excellent color profiles – many with corresponding dorsal schemes and paint matches – superbly sample the sumptuous swath of Arab warplane camouflage.


Conclusion

 

What a terrific tome!  Text hints that substantial parts of Vol 6 are complete.  Here’s hoping that we don’t have to wait another year for Harpia’s next illuminating Arab MiGs installment!

Robustly recommended!

With thanks to HARPIA PUBLISHING for the review sample.



Available in North America from CASEMATE:

www.casematepublishing.com


Review Copyright 2014 by David L. Veres
This Page Created on 18 December, 2014
Last updated 18 December, 2014

Back to HyperScale Main Page